“How do we make sure our website doesn’t sound like every other arts organization?”

Last month, the executive director at Locust Projects in Miami asked me this question during a PR strategy session.

It was the perfect question because it highlighted something I see constantly in the nonprofit world. Organizations with incredible missions, transformative programs, and passionate communities often sound exactly the same when they try to tell their story. 

With arts funding facing significant cuts and an uncertain economy that could negatively impact nonprofit organizations, now is the time to stand out, connect authentically with supporters, and prepare your organization for whatever comes next. Here are the practical PR strategies nonprofits should put in place right now.

Clarify What Makes You Different


The first step is to audit your website and messaging like a first-time visitor would. Can someone understand your unique value proposition in 30 seconds? Most nonprofit websites are filled with mission statements that could apply to dozens of organizations.

Take Locust Projects in Miami. They could describe themselves as “supporting emerging artists” like numerous other arts nonprofits. Instead, their homepage should lead with specifics: “Miami’s longest-running alternative art space commissioning ambitious new work” and highlight measurable impact like “500+ artists supported over 26 years” and “free legal services provided annually through LegalARTLink.”

Just as important, they should SHOW what “ambitious” really means. Locust Projects has encouraged artists to create bold, risk-taking works and they are not precious about their space like traditional galleries. For example, artists have jackhammered floors, fired up working kilns, and even staged synchronized swimming performances in above-ground pools as part of their installations. Pairing that kind of visual storytelling with artist testimonials would make the difference from the moment someone lands on the homepage of their website.

And rather than leaning on mission-speak like “fostering artistic growth,” they could spotlight the transformation: “An artist who debuted work here went on to secure gallery representation in New York.” Lead with the human story and the change you create, not the process.

Use AI tools like ChatGPT or Claude to pressure-test your copy. Ask them to flag phrases that sound generic compared to other organizations in your space. The results might surprise you.

Master the Art of Storytelling

Powerful storytelling in nonprofits is a must. It’s what drives donations, inspires loyalty, and creates the emotional connection that sustains support through difficult times.

These three types of stories consistently resonate:

Impact Journeys: Show the transformation of the people you serve. Don’t just say you helped someone. Walk through their journey from where they started to where they are now.

Community Ripple Effects: Demonstrate how local support creates wider change. When someone donates $100, what happens in the community as a result?

Supporter Spotlights: Let volunteers, donors and board members explain why they support your organization in their own words. Capture and share interviews in video on the homepage of your website, on your social media, in email newsletters and more. These authentic testimonials are more powerful than any fundraising copy you could write.

The easiest way to gather these stories is through a simple recorded Zoom meeting or Google Form with questions like “Why do you choose to support our organization?” and “What moment made you realize this work matters?” Repurpose the responses across press releases, grant applications, and social media.

Focus Your Social Media Strategy

Nonprofits don’t need to be everywhere. Pick two social media platforms where your audience consistently shows up and do them well. For example: 

LinkedIn for institutional positioning. Share board updates, grant announcements, donor recognition, and policy news. Be sure to tag those you’re talking about so they’re more inclined to share the post with their followers. This platform can help you reach foundations, corporate partners, and major donors who make funding decisions.

Instagram for program and behind-the-scenes content. Visual storytelling works best here, whether it’s installation shots, artist processes, or volunteers and community events in action.

Create content pillars (repeatable categories of posts) so you’re not starting from scratch every time. For example: Monday artist spotlights, Wednesday behind-the-scenes content, and Friday community impact stories. This makes consistent posting manageable even with a small team.

Turn Supporters and Local Influencers Into Ambassadors

Your most powerful marketing tool isn’t paid advertising. It’s the people who already believe in your mission.

Make supporter visibility part of your regular content creation strategy:

  • Welcome and tag new board members on LinkedIn
  • Launch a “Why I Support” video series featuring donors, board members and volunteers
  • Use throwback posts to highlight longtime supporters
  • Invite local influencers (artists, curators, community leaders, lifestyle content creators) to private events and provide them with content to make sharing easy

Strong relationships with supporters today become your safety net during funding challenges tomorrow.

Make Your Content Discoverable in AI Searches

People are increasingly using AI tools like Google’s SEO, ChatGPT or Claude to conduct their searches.

Make your content easy for search engines and AI to understand:

  • Add an FAQ page (“How does [Your Arts Organization] support emerging artists?”)
  • Use conversational blog titles (e.g., “What Miami artists need right now” or “Why supporting local nonprofits matters”)
  • Apply schema markup to your website
  • Write donation page copy in Q&A format (“What happens when I donate $100 to support local artists?”)

When your content directly answers common questions, you’re more likely to appear in search results and AI responses.

Create Systems That Scale

The key to sustainable PR for nonprofits is creating processes that work efficiently with small teams and limited resources. Instead of reinventing the wheel every time you need content, build systems that make your job easier.

Use AI to streamline your workflow:

  • Run website audits to identify confusing language or missing calls to action
  • Draft questionnaires for artists, volunteers and donors 
  • Train AI tools to write in your organization’s voice and tone so they can draft content for you
  • Generate ideas when you’re stuck on social media content

Beyond AI, create templates you can reuse again and again. Develop formats for donor spotlights, artist interviews, and press releases. When you have a proven structure, creating new content becomes much faster.

Plan your efforts with a simple 90-day calendar. Each month, commit to publishing one impact story, featuring one supporter, and reaching out to one media contact. This approach builds momentum without overwhelming your team.

Finally, resist the urge to track everything. Pick one or two metrics that actually matter to your mission, like donor and volunteer retention rates or how long people spend on your website. Measuring what counts is better than counting what’s easy to measure.

The Organizations That Thrive

In uncertain times, the nonprofits that survive and thrive are the ones that tell authentic stories, clarify their unique value, and make supporters feel valued. They don’t wait for perfect conditions or unlimited budgets. They start with what they have and build momentum from there.

Whether you’re running an arts organization or a nonprofit, the principles are the same. Pick one action from this list: a donor questionnaire, a LinkedIn post series, or a website audit, and put it in place this month.

Your mission is too important to get lost in the noise. Let’s make sure people hear it.

Need help developing a comprehensive PR strategy for your nonprofit? Our team specializes in helping organizations tell their stories authentically and build lasting community support. Contact us to discuss how we can increase your impact.

5 PR Actions Any Nonprofit Can Start This Month (Even on a Budget)

☐ Audit your homepage – Can a first-time visitor understand what makes you different in 30 seconds? If not, rewrite your opening paragraph.

☐ Create a template Google Form – Ask 3 artists and 3 donors: “What impact has our organization had on you?” Use their responses for social posts and grant applications.

☐ Post one supporter spotlight – Feature a board member, volunteer, or donor on LinkedIn via a video or photo about why they support your mission.

☐ Add an FAQ page to your website – Answer 5-7 common questions like “How can I volunteer?” and “What happens when I donate $50?”

☐ Set up a content calendar – Plan one impact story, one supporter feature, and one media outreach for each of the next three months.

Share This Story!